38 lines
2.8 KiB
Markdown
38 lines
2.8 KiB
Markdown
# Advisor evidence
|
|
|
|
## M9 capability recommendations
|
|
|
|
`/api/v1/capability-advisor` evaluates each contract independently. No active deployment yields `REQUIRES_MORE_EVIDENCE`; a proven LAB deployment without a typed suite yields `LAB_READY`; completed evidence satisfying every declared threshold yields `PROMOTION_ELIGIBLE`; failed cases, failed runs or threshold regressions yield `BLOCKED`. These states are advisory and never trigger promotion. Retrieval's comparison-specific `KEEP_CURRENT` policy remains intact.
|
|
|
|
Advisor recommendations are deterministic outputs of a versioned persisted policy. Project-local
|
|
evaluation is evidence class A and outranks generic, external and vendor evidence. Critical
|
|
regressions, supply-chain failures and runtime-fit failures are hard gates; latency remains a distinct
|
|
operational dimension.
|
|
|
|
Each recommendation preserves metric deltas, critical regressions, resource evidence, migration
|
|
impact, blockers, rationale, confidence and policy version. Dismissal is supported, but Advisor has no
|
|
approve or promote endpoint. M7's real ExampleRAG recommendations legitimately resolve to
|
|
`KEEP_CURRENT` or `REQUIRES_MORE_EVIDENCE`.
|
|
|
|
M10 lets Advisor consume scheduler readiness, authoritative ResourceEnvelope freshness and measured
|
|
co-residency as operational evidence. It may explain that a candidate is technically eligible but
|
|
not proven for sustained coexistence. Scheduler evidence never overrides quality, supply-chain,
|
|
migration or approval gates and never triggers an automatic promotion.
|
|
|
|
M11 adds immutable project-fit evidence. It is scoped to one project binding and cannot make a global
|
|
“best model” claim. Advisor exposes engineering integration separately from project production fit:
|
|
ExampleVision vision engineering is `PASS`, while project fit remains `REQUIRES_MORE_EVIDENCE`, production
|
|
validation is `DEFERRED_EXTERNAL_VALIDATION` and production action is `NONE`. Its speech flow is
|
|
`KEEP_LAB` because four TTS cases do not establish microphone quality. Only reviewed `OWNER_PHOTO`
|
|
evidence may satisfy the ExampleVision production gate; public physical captures and catalog references
|
|
retain their weaker typed class. Blockers or critical failures make `PROMOTION_ELIGIBLE` invalid, and
|
|
the referenced deployment must implement the binding's exact contract.
|
|
|
|
M12 consumes Advisor output only as evidence. Advisor may recommend `PROMOTION_ELIGIBLE`, but only
|
|
the lifecycle engine can evaluate the active policy revision, create an approval snapshot and permit
|
|
an immutable plan. There is no Advisor-to-promotion shortcut.
|
|
|
|
M13 may reference an Advisor/project-fit verdict in an immutable validation snapshot. Advisor still
|
|
cannot create, start, validate or cut over a migration; missing or adverse project evidence remains a
|
|
separate production blocker even when an isolated technical rehearsal passes.
|