Phase 0.8 read-only on-device preflight

Audit date: 2026-07-18. Decision: READ_ONLY_PREFLIGHT_BLOCKED.

This is an offline admissibility audit. No on-device preflight session was started, no connection to the PS5 was made, and no collector was run against the PS5. No file, configuration, service, process, artifact, autoload setting, or retry state on the console was touched. Local documentation and manifest changes are outside that console-action statement.

The attached preflight form requires both an exact permission record and a collector whose reads demonstrably cannot change atime, audit logs, caches, metadata, process state, or on-device logs. Neither condition can currently be filled truthfully. The form's own fail-closed rule therefore requires STOP-RO.

Authorization record

Field	Recorded value
explicit read-only preflight permission	absent; no exact text/reference was supplied
connection authorized	`false`
installation authorized	`false`
lifecycle authorized	`false`
execution authorized	`false`
automatic retry	`false`

The request to read and act on a blank checklist is not recorded as an exact, artifact-independent authorization sentence. This finding alone prevents an on-device session. It does not prevent this offline source audit.

Collector review

Stock Payload Manager HTTP

The exact public v0.3.1 source is commit cfbc70f30f419b09bf2b52283f7409e2d3117ee1.

This candidate is UNSAFE for the Phase-0.8 read-only contract:

src/http_server.c:131-152 calls log_server_set_active() for every non-OPTIONS request before route dispatch;
src/log_server.c:20-23 implements that call by writing server_active_flag = 1;
src/http_server.c:847-871 dispatches /autoload_status to pldmgr_autoload_get_status() and opens /data/pldmgr/autoload.txt;
src/autoload.c:44-48 writes autoload_triggered = 1; the worker at src/autoload.c:78-93 uses that flag to leave its frontend-wait state and start the countdown;
src/http_server.c:911-930 also opens the autoload file for /get_config;
non-noisy routes call pldmgr_log() at src/http_server.c:479-481; src/log_server.c:25-55 prints to stdout and mutates the in-process ring, log version, mutex/condition state, and waiting clients.

Even /version, which is filtered from the explicit request log, first calls log_server_set_active(). Therefore an apparently informational endpoint is not sufficient evidence of a no-side-effect collector. /autoload_status must not be used at all under this contract.

Pinned source-file SHA-256 values:

File	SHA-256
`src/http_server.c`	`35cf5d8f0dd44cf64ceab5e4b0ecc09413c82d7e9946ba9de2ca4b1898631fdd`
`src/autoload.c`	`7051cab3ee1a3e0b9f6498000565eb9e160b9c63efa1771f250e98ec3aa4ae67`
`src/log_server.c`	`659095f43df1bbe8eb24acb165f027edc277af1e60aabb26ba9e3920b233d6f1`

Direct filesystem or process collector

No exact collector, version, source, transport, or operation set was supplied. No evidence proves noatime behavior, suppression of audit records, absence of caches, absence of network/service counters, or absence of on-device logging. Classifying these effects as “probably harmless” would contradict the required Onbekend -> STOP-RO rule.

Historical Phase-0.6 endpoint observations are not reused as current Phase-0.8 evidence. They lack current pre/post identity and were gathered under a different, less strict observation boundary.

Gate state

Preflight section	Review	Reason
permission	`STOP-RO`	exact permission text/reference absent
collector	`STOP-RO`	side-effect freedom unproven
stock HTTP collector	`STOP-RO`	proven process-state mutations
two-source firmware 9.60	`STOP-GATE`	one user attestation, no two current device sources
live elfldr path/object/hash	`STOP-GATE`	no current admissible observation
live Payload Manager path/object/hash	`STOP-GATE`	no current admissible observation
processes/services/listeners	`STOP-GATE`	current topology and ownership absent
autoload/startup/retry	`STOP-GATE`	authoritative sources not collected
separate backup destination	`STOP-GATE`	device, space, and reserve unproven
stock elfldr rollback backup	`STOP-GATE`	exact separate backup unproven
stock Payload Manager rollback backup	`HARD STOP-GATE`	exact separate on-device backup unproven

The expected stock identities remain reference values only:

elfldr: 397000 bytes, 092d16ee0ede0c494947efd38d1a17bbd7cc4b022d3858ea898833c188c703e8;
Payload Manager: 2050320 bytes, 518740adbacccb9094fadb07dd424c53ee290f38306449ccc9d6957fdf813c0b.

They are not claims about the console's current state.

Minimum evidence to reopen

Exact permission text and a stable task reference authorizing only this read-only preflight, while leaving installation, lifecycle execution, transfer, artifact execution, and automatic retry unauthorized.
A pinned public collector and transport with a complete source and environment proof excluding file, atime, metadata, audit-log, cache, process-state, service-state, network-state, and on-device-log mutation.
Two authoritative current firmware sources that agree exactly on 9.60.
A side-effect-free collection plan for current object identities, full metadata, hashes, process/service ownership, ports 8084/8085/9021, and all autoload/startup/retry sources, including stable pre/post observations.
Proof that separate, already-present, byte-exact rollback objects exist. The stock Payload Manager backup is a hard gate.

The stock Payload Manager HTTP interface cannot satisfy item 2 without a different, separately reviewed implementation. No workaround is attempted.

Final state

dataset complete: false;
open STOP-RO: true;
open STOP-GATE: true;
Payload Manager backup exact/current: UNPROVEN;
installation approval: NOT AUTHORIZED;
lifecycle approval: NOT AUTHORIZED;
execution authorized: false;
automatic retry: false.

The complete machine-readable record is manifests/runtime/phase-0.8-read-only-preflight.json.

6.1 KiB Raw Permalink Blame History